Episode 2

full
Published on:

12th Jun 2023

I Knew They Would | Episode 2

I Knew They Would | Episode 2

When news of Megan’s disappearance spreads throughout the community, everyone is a bit shocked. News agencies in Salt Lake City had already reported another kidnapping that day, Elizabeth Smart. The similarities are striking, but the detectives don’t jump to any conclusions about Megan. 

Join our host, Emily as she takes you through the rest of the morning and afternoon. From personal interviews, you will see the day from the perspective of Darrel’s secretary, Misty, her friends Kiera and Whitney, and the deputies involved. 

Interviews in the order they are heard: 

Misty was Darrel’s secretary. That morning Darrel and Megan’s grandpa left to go help with the search for Megan. Misty hung back just in case Megan called the office. 

Whitney was also a close friend. Megan had planned to go on a camping trip with Whitney and her family in the coming days. She was also interviewed by the police, helping them understand Megan’s state of mind at the time. 

Keira was a close friend and neighbor to Megan. She was interviewed by police to help them investigate and work out where Megan might have gone. Megan’s grandpa picks her up. She tells police that if Megan had left on her own, she would have taken her Scooby-Doo blanket still lying on the trampoline. 

Detective Sergeant Kevin Cox sends detectives to help with the investigation and starts heading over to Megan’s home. 

Sergeant Brian Lovell talks about the normal checklist police go through for missing persons. He also mentions the disappearance of Amber Hoopes. 

Brian Stositch was the responding deputy to Megan’s home. He talks to the family to find out who they have contacted to look for Megan. He is told by Darrel that the family dog had been barking a lot in the early morning hours. 

Not interviewed but mentioned: 

Darrel - Megan’s father

Gina - Megan’s mother

Elizabeth Smart - Kidnapped from her home in SLC on June 5, 2002

Amber Hoopes - Disappeared from her grandparents’ home on Sept. 14, 2001

Key Points

  • Elizabeth Smart’s kidnapping is considered to be connected but is ruled out
  • It was unlike her to go anywhere without her Scooby-Doo blanket
  • Police consider a connection to Amber Hoopes’s disappearance 
  • Misty receives a call from Megan at Darrel’s office

You can find more information about Amber Hoopes at:

 https://bonnevillesheriff.com/news/2021-09/amber-hoopes-missing-person-case-20-years-later/

If you have any information about Amber Hoopes' disappearance, contact Bonneville County Sheriff’s Office at 208-529-1200, online at www.ifcrime.org, or through the P3tips App on your mobile device, available in the Apple or Google Play store.


Music Production by Morgan Celner https://www.morgancelner.com/

Cover Art and Logo by Pammie Jane https://www.pammiejane.com/

She’s Missing is a Search Party Media Production https://www.shesmissingpodcast.com/



Special Thanks to: 

Bonneville County Sheriff’s Office


Next Week…

We will go back to the early morning hours of June 5th and hear about Megan’s kidnapping from Megan herself. 

Listen for free

Show artwork for She's Missing

About the Podcast

She's Missing
The Disappearance of Amber Hoopes
“She's Missing” is a narrated, true crime podcast that invites listeners to join an immersive journey into stories of missing girls and women. Season 2 takes a closer look at the disappearance of Amber Hoopes from her home in Southeast Idaho. This journey will take you through the emotions felt by those most closely affected by her abduction. As the story builds, you will see how new clues and the kidnapping of Megan, brought answers and more questions that are still unanswered to this day.

Season 1 delves into the disappearance of Megan, a 14-year-old girl abducted from her trampoline in Southeast Idaho, on June 5th, 2002. Hosted by Emily, the podcast presents an unprecedented blend of personal interviews, investigative twists, and emotional resonance, transcending the true crime genre.

"She's Missing" strives to show the miraculous story of Megan's kidnapping, featuring candid interviews with family, friends, and authorities. This documentary-style narrative is not just about the investigation but the impact on those connected to Megan. The podcast also raises intriguing parallels between Megan's case and the disappearance of Amber Hoopes, from September 14, 2001.

Visit our website www.shesmissingpodcast.com for visual aids.
Support This Show

About your host

Profile picture for Emily Downey

Emily Downey

Emily is a true crime enthusiast. As a child, her mom would read mystery novels aloud on long car rides and instilled that love for a good mystery in Emily. Her interest in unsolved disappearances started with Stephanie Crane, a 9-year-old who disappeared from Challis, ID on Oct. 11, 1993. Emily was also 9 at the time and the story really emphasized the fact that even in small towns evil is lurking.